Design Amid : Design + Lifestyle Magazine

 

 

 

Login / Register
Home / Cover | Masthead | Categories | Advertise | DA Awards | Contents | + Submit an Article or News November 21, 2017

Positive Presentation Bias


Positive Presentation Bias

You must have heard that beautiful people get hired easier; but does that mean handsome projects are more often awarded? Learn about the Positive Presentation Bias and how to avoid it.

In judgment and decision making, a cognitive bias is the human tendency to make a systematic decision focused more on on cognitive factors rather than the reality. In the case of Positive Presentation Bias, designs and projects that are better represented, in a design competition, are considered better.
The Positive Presentation Bias was discovered due to the statistical inconsistency in the jury scores of design submissions in the A’ Design Award & Competition: Normally, entries in A’ Design Award & Competition are voted against multiple evaluation criterion, one of the such criteria is the “Presentation Quality” with a relatively low weight on it. However, when a sample of 500 design submissions were analyzed in detail and re-voted analytically, it was discovered that jury members tend to give higher scores to designs whose visual representations were made better, regardless of the intrinsic properties of the design.
A’ Design Award & Competition featured 3 types of jury members; Academics, Professionals and Focus Group Members. The highest presentation bias occurred for the Focus Group Members in general. Academics & Professionals have the lowest presentation bias, when it came to voting entries in their own expertise areas; however they tended to display also a significant amount of bias when they were voting entries in other categories.
The Positive Presentation Bias could be related to other existing cognitive biases such as the “Framing Effect” i.e. drawing different conclusions from the same information, depending on how that information is presented, or the “Focusing effect” i.e. the tendency to place too much importance on one aspect of an event, in any case the presentation bias effects the competition outcomes in a negative manner, and thus it is required to be reduced or removed. There are several ways to reduce this bias.
Positive Presentation Bias
For example, to remove the Positive Presentation Bias, A’ Design Award & Competition implemented several tools and approaches: 1. Uniform Submission System, 2. Uniform Jury Presentation System, 3. Preliminary Score and Feedbacks for Presentation, 4. Detailed Presentation Guidelines Book with Hints and Suggestions, 5. Submission Optimizer Software. 6. Showcasing Prior Winner Works, 7. Voting Guidelines for Jury Members. The purpose of all the tools is to push the presentation quality of entries to a uniform, high level such that when jury members would vote on the submissions, the presentation of the entries would be less relevant because they would all be good, and therefore submissions could be judged more on their intrinsic qualities; thus the Positive Presentation Bias could be removed or reduced.
To avoid being effected by the Positive Presentation Bias, designers are suggest to make the best presentation they could for their projects, in this case, they could perhaps also utilize the bias to their advantage, or alternatively competitions and awards can implement systems and tools to reduce the bias as seen in A’ Design Award & Competition. Designers could also get help from professional photographers or graphic designers to have their works presented better; most designers are in a biased position when it comes to presentation; they tend to overestimate their skills. For example being a perfect furniture designer does not automatically entitle an individual to be a perfect visual communication designer. Being a perfect architect or interior designer does not guarantee perfect photography that is required for a good communication.
REFERENCES/BIBLIOGRAPHY:
https://www.adesignaward.com/positive-presentation-bias.html

This article was added on Monday, 27th of January, 2014 at 08.26 am by author Onur Cobanli Tags: visual presentation bias, communication bias, cognitive biases. Read our copyright policy here.
 

VIA:

www.adesignaward.com

 

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE:


Chengdu Design Week

Via Tortona and Zona Brera, the discovery of the last frontiers of creativity

Find the best Architects, Artists and Designers to work with Online

Operae _ article by Grazia Berardinelli

Walking through Salone Satellite 2012

Award Winning Designs

DA Design Awards

Design Award Logo Application Examples

Salone del Mobile 2015

History of Design Competitions

Zona Tortona: new technologies in a safe eco system

Cersaie 2011

Why a good design award should cover more categories?

FUORISALONE MILAN 2016, THE DESIGN CELEBRATION

Elena Galli Giallini and Spawton Architecture complete the architectural interior design of Sino Ocean Taikoo Li Chengdu retail arcade

CLICK HERE TO SEE EVEN MORE

 

SEARCH

 
Random Article
» Chengdu Design Week
Advertisements
A' Design Award

CATEGORIES

Furniture, Decorative Items and Homeware Design
Packaging Design
Architecture, Building and Structure Design
Fashion, Apparel and Garment Design
Lighting Products and Lighting Projects Design
Toy, Games and Hobby Products Design
Digital and Electronic Devices Design
Interior Space and Exhibition Design
Vehicle, Mobility and Transportation Design
Interface and Interaction Design
Home Appliances Design
Graphics and Visual Communication Design
Computer Graphics and 3D Model Design
Photography and Photo Manipulation Design
Engineering and Technical Design
Scientific Instruments, Medical Devices and Research Equipment Design
Movie and Animation Design
Food, Beverage and Culinary Arts Design
Building Materials, Construction Components, Structures & Systems Design
Social Design
Idea Design
Arts, Crafts and Ready-Made Design
Meta, Strategic and Service Design
Unexpected Design
Information Technologies Design
Hardware, Power and Hand Tools Design
Young Design
Heavy Machinery Design
Performing Arts, Style and Scenery Design
Music, Audio and Sound Design
Writing, Literature and Content Design
Excellence in Design
Diligence and Intelligence in Design
Actor, Talent and Model Design
Hospitality, Recreation, Travel and Tourism Design
Futuristic Design
Social and Behavioral Sciences Design
Natural Sciences and Mathematics Design
Awards, Prize and Competitions Design
Event and Happening Design
Sports, Entertainment and Recreation Equipment Design
Textile, Fabric, Textures, Patterns and Cloth Design
Safety Clothing and Personal Protective Equipment Design
Beauty, Personal Care and Cosmetic Products Design
Chemical Products and Consumables Design
Sales, Contact Center and Customer Service Design
Pet Supplies and Products for Animals Design
Banking and Finance Instruments Design
Jewelry, Eyewear and Watch Design
Bakeware, Tableware, Drinkware and Cookware Design
Baby, Kids' and Children's Products Design
Fashion and Travel Accessories Design
Art Materials, Stationery Supplies and Gift Items Design
Prosumer Products, Tools, and Machinery Design
Security and Surveillance Products Design
Bathroom Furniture and Sanitary Ware Design
Manufacturing and Processing Machinery Design
Energy Products and Devices Design
Business Plan and Corporate Operational Plans Design
Information Processing Tools Design
Street Furniture Design
Landscape Planning and Garden Design
Urban Planning and Urban Design
Human Resources and HR Programs Design
Education and Training Content Design
Yacht and Marine Vessels Design
Car and Land Based Motor Vehicles Design
Agriculture, Horticulture and Fisheries Design
Aerospace and Aircraft Design
Multidisciplinary and Interdisciplinary Design
Core Resources Manufacturing and Extraction Design
Spacecraft, Spaceplanes and Spaceship Design
Generative, Algorithmic and Parametric Design
Digital and Broadcasting Media Design
Print and Published Media Design
Construction and Real Estate Projects Design
Musical Instruments Design
Differently Abled and Seniors' Assistance Design
Public Awareness, Volunteerism, and Society Design
Governance and Public Services Design
Creative Legacy, Retro and Evergreen Design
Cultural Heritage and Culture Industry Design
Luxury Design
Mobile Technologies, Applications and Software Design
Advertising, Marketing and Communication Design
Creative Industry and Lifelong Design
Cybernetics, Prosthesis and Bio-Engineering Design
Radical Innovation and New Technologies Design
Wearable Technologies Design
Engineering, Construction and Infrastructure Design
Footwear, Shoes and Boots Design
Furniture Accessories, Hardware and Materials Design
Limited Edition and Custom Design
Design Quality and Innovation
Sustainable Products, Projects and Green Design
Design for X
3D Printed Forms and Products Design
Disposable and Single-Use Product Design
Website and Web Design
Ease of Use and Universal Design
Adult Toys and Products Design
Methods, Techniques and Strategies Design
Legwear, Pantyhose and Hosiery Design
Industrial Design
Spatial Design
Graphics Design
Strategic Design
Interaction Design
Structured Product Design
Advanced Design and Design Research
Concealed, Hidden and Secret Design

PAGES

For Index, click here.
Google Advertisements
More Advertisements
Design Competition
Design Mega Store
OMC Design Studios
Copyrights ©2017 | Privacy Policy | Sitemap | RSS Feed | Register | Login